action figures admiral ackbar Advertising ai alderaan Alec Guiness Architecture Art artoo atari AT-AT a-team auction AV Club beeb bib fortuna blu-ray Boba Fett Books boxing calgary herald candy cantina cars cartoon chewbacca China christmas Clone Wars Clothing Collectibles Comics conspiracy copyright corrupting youth costumes Crime Darth Vader david prowse death star deathstarpr Dick Cheney Disco diy documentaries Dr Seuss easter egg eBay effects etsy ewoks expanded universe fanboys food Food football Furnishings Games Gary Kurtz gawthrok George Lucas grand moff tarkin Grenadier growing up han solo harmonica harrison ford Hasbro hockey hologram homophobia honeymoon Hot Problems humour Humour hygiene izzard jabba jar jar jaxxon jedi Jefferson Starship jewellery john booth john williams Joseph Campbell judaism jumping the shark Kenner Law leia Life Day lightsabers Los Angeles Times luke mark hamill marvel Meco midichlorians millennium falcon miniatures Minnesota money montreal canadiens Movies Music My book myth nasa needlecraft New York New York Times New Zealand nostalgia Nostalgia Obi-Wan Kenobi pants Parenting pets Pets plasticine please stop Politics porkins porn posters pranks prequelitis Prequels prequels psa radio ralph mcquarrie ratherchildish Relationships Religion reviews right on brother Science science fiction sellout shakespeare shoes silence sillof solo sorry special editions Sports Star Wars Holiday Special Star Wars Uncut starwarsremix stormtroopers stupidity tauntaun Television The Muppets threepio Topps tortoises Toys tractor beam tthreepio tuna tupac Turkey underwear USSR vader valentine's day violin Volkswagen wales wampa wedding West End wow wtf wygant yoda zazzle

Entries in reviews (2)

Tuesday
Oct042011

Original New York Times review of Star Wars

Craig's MovieBlog has kindly, and perhaps illegally, reproduced Vincent Cambie's 1977 review of Star Wars for the New York Times. It's a great read. I particularly like the description of Alec Guiness's character as "a fellow in possession of what's called 'the force'". Here's an excerpt but click below for the whole review:

When the film opens, dark times have fallen upon the galactic empire once ruled, we are given to believe, from a kind of space-age Camelot. Against these evil tyrants there is, in progress, a rebellion led by a certain Princess Leia Organa, a pretty round-faced young woman of old-fashioned pluck who, before you can catch your breath, has been captured by the guardians of the empire. Their object is to retrieve some secret plans that can be the empire's undoing.

That's about all the plot that anyone of voting age should be required to keep track of. The story of Star Wars could be written on the head of a pin and still leave room for the Bible. It is, rather, a breathless succession of escapes, pursuits, dangerous missions, unexpected encounters, with each one ending in some kind of defeat until the final one.

These adventures involve, among others, an ever-optimistic young man named Luke Skywalker (Mark Hamill), who is innocent without being naive; Han Solo (Harrison Ford), a free-booting freelance spaceship captain who goes where he can make the most money; and an old mystic named Ben Kenobi (Alec Guinness), one of the last of the Old Guard, a fellow in possession of what's called "the force," a mixture of what appears to be ESP and early Christian faith.

Craig's MovieBlog: 1977 NYT Star Wars Review

Friday
Sep162011

Nicely done review of the Star Wars Blu-ray discs

Jamie Benning is a great choice as a reviewer for the Star Wars Blu Ray discs. See what he has to say on the Wired GeekDad blog:

Firstly, as any Star Wars fan now knows, Lucas has been tinkering again. Not only were they tweaked in the 1997 Special Editions in the cinema, but Lucasfilm went back and made further alterations for the 2004 DVD release. Well, the Force-fueled OCD continues with this Blu-ray release. Not only does Ben Kenobi s Krayt Dragon call now sound like he s stepped on a Lego brick with no shoes on, Darth Vader now shouts Nooooo! at the end of RotJ mirroring the characters most cringe-worthy moment from the Prequel finale. Both are unwelcome additions for any Original Trilogy fan, as is the fact that no room was found to include the original versions of the films. But, the compromise for me is that there are some 40 hours of extras with this set. That, after all, is why I have shelled out my hard earned cash once again.

Wired: GeekDad: Jamie Benning Reviews the Star Wars Blu-ray set